The pros and cons of renting vs buying an apartment in Melbourne

There are both pros and cons between buying an apartment and renting one in Victoria's capital city
The pros and cons of renting vs buying an apartment in Melbourne
Rent or buying an apartment
Mike BirdJanuary 9, 2023

Deciding whether to rent or buy an apartment in Melbourne can be a tough decision, as both options have their own set of pros and cons.

Here's a closer look at the benefits and drawbacks of both renting and buying an apartment in Melbourne:

Pros of renting:

More flexibility

Renting an apartment allows you to move more easily and without the burden of selling a property.

Lower upfront costs

Renting generally requires a smaller upfront investment than buying, as you don't have to come up with a down payment or closing costs.

Lower monthly costs

In some cases, renting can be cheaper than buying on a monthly basis, especially if you're unable to afford a large mortgage payment.

No maintenance costs

As a renter, you're not responsible for maintaining the apartment or paying for repairs.

Cons of renting:

Lack of control

As a renter, you don't have control over the property and may have to deal with landlords who are unresponsive to your needs.

Limited ability to make changes

Renters are generally not allowed to make major changes to the property, such as renovations or additions.

No equity

When you rent, you're not building equity in the apartment or house you're renting.

Pros of buying

Building equity

When you buy an apartment, you're building equity in the property as you pay off your mortgage.

This can be a good long-term investment, as the value of the property may increase over time.

Control

As a homeowner, you have more control over the property and can make changes and improvements as you see fit.

Potential tax benefits

Owning an apartment may offer tax benefits such as the ability to deduct mortgage interest and property taxes from your taxes.

Cons for buying

Higher upfront costs

Buying an apartment requires a larger upfront investment, as you'll need to come up with a down payment and closing costs.

Higher monthly costs

In some cases, buying an apartment may be more expensive on a monthly basis than renting, especially if you have a large mortgage payment.

Maintenance costs

As a homeowner, you're responsible for maintaining the apartment and paying for repairs, which can be costly.

Lack of flexibility

Buying an apartment may limit your flexibility to move or change living arrangements, as you'll need to sell the property before you can move.

Ultimately, whether to rent or buy an apartment in Melbourne depends on your individual circumstances and financial goals. It's important to carefully consider both options and weigh the pros and cons before making a decision.

Mike Bird

Mike Bird is the Chief Executive Officer and Co-founder of Apartments.com.au, Australia’s leading marketplace for off the plan property. With a background in digital media, technology, and platform growth, Mike brings a strategic, customer-first mindset to the business, driving Urban’s mission to simplify the new property buying journey and bring transparency to the process.

Since establishing what was Urban.com.au back in 2019, Mike has overseen significant product innovation and expansion of Urban’s data and editorial capabilities—solidifying the platform as a trusted destination for buyers, developers, and agents alike. Under his leadership, Urban has scaled its developer partnerships, improved buyer engagement through enhanced UX and personalisation, and strengthened its position as the go-to source for off the plan insights across Australia’s capital cities.

As CEO, Mike continues to lead Apartments.com.au with a focus on innovation, data-driven decisions, and a commitment to helping Australians make confident, informed property choices.

Editor's Picks

Caloundra transformation continues with RCQ's Bulcock Street plans
First look: Third.i plots 500-unit redevelopment of Gladesville Village Shopping Centre
Incontro Apartments snapped up as Cedar Woods announces builder
Overseas buyer shares why she chose Melbourne Square in Southbank: Urban Buyer Q&A
Zero stamp duty available at The Collection in Alphington